Craving a delicious slice in Oxford, PA? Our shopping guide to pizza in Oxford helps you find the freshest pies, hidden gems, and local favorites. Whether you’re a longtime resident or just passing through, discover the best pizzerias and delivery options to satisfy your cravings. Explore your perfect pizza experience and support the vibrant local food scene—one slice at a time!
Comparing Pizza in Oxford, PA: Types, Styles, and Dining Options
| Restaurant | Pizza Styles Offered | Gluten-Free Options | Specialty Pizzas | Dine-In | Delivery | Takeout | BYOB | Family-Friendly | Signature/Notable Features |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| La Sicilia | Traditional, Sicilian, Gourmet | Inquire | Margherita, Meat Lovers, White | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Contactless delivery, expanded menu |
| Andre’s Pizza | NY-Style, Sicilian, White, Gourmet, Gluten-Free | Yes | Dragon Fire, Taco, Primavera, Tomato Pie | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | Large, diverse pizza and entrée menu |
| Bravo Pizza | Neapolitan, Sicilian, Deep Dish, Stuffed, Gluten-Free | Yes | Calabrese, General Tso, Mediterranean, Holiday | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | Located in shopping center, loaded fries |
| Margherita’s Pizza | Classic Italian, Sicilian | Inquire | Signature Stromboli, Owner-prepared pies | Yes | Inquire | Yes | Yes | Yes | Handmade daily, renowned for strombolis |
| Teo’s Pizza & Grill | Classic, Italian-American | Inquire | Teo’s Special | No | No | Yes | No | Casual | Garlic knots, fresh rolls, consistency |
| Pats Select | Flatbread, Classic, Gourmet | Inquire | Extensive menu including pasta, flatbread | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | Catering, family-style, large variety |
Compatibility: Matching Pizza Types with Dining Preferences and Dietary Needs
When choosing the right pizza in Oxford, PA, compatibility is ultimately about how a pizzeria fits your taste profile, dietary requirements, and occasion.
1. Dining Style
- Family Dine-In: Look for venues like Margherita’s and La Sicilia that emphasize family-friendly environments and generous portions.
- Quick Takeout or Delivery: Andre’s Pizza, Bravo Pizza, and Pats Select offer streamlined takeout and convenient delivery.
- Casual Eats: Teo’s Pizza & Grill is ideal for a walk-in/takeout experience or casual lunch stop.
2. Dietary Compatibility
- Gluten-Free: Andre’s Pizza and Bravo Pizza clearly offer gluten-free pizzas. Other locations may have gluten-friendly options; always confirm before ordering.
- Vegetarian & Vegan: Many establishments offer veggie-topped pizzas, white pizzas, and robust salads. Bravo and Andre’s especially feature diverse veggie or Mediterranean selections.
- BYOB Preferences: Both Margherita’s and La Sicilia are BYOB; if you prefer to bring your own wine or beer, these are the top choices.
3. Group Size and Special Events
- Large Gatherings/Catering: Pats Select emphasizes catering and family meals. Many places also accept party orders.
- Intimate Dinners: Choose venues with a welcoming, cozy atmosphere like Margherita’s or La Sicilia for a more personal dining experience.
Function: What Makes Each Oxford Pizza Stand Out?
Oxford, PA boasts a surprisingly wide variety of pizza experiences, each fulfilling different culinary functions:
Traditionalists
- Classic NY-Style & Neapolitan: Andre’s serves very well-reviewed NY-style thin crusts, while Bravo features both Neapolitan and deep-dish pies.
- Sicilian & Roman Pizzas: For thick, hearty slices, Andre’s and Bravo both serve Sicilian options with a satisfying chew.
Adventurers
- Specialty Toppings: Exotic creations like Bravo’s General Tso Chicken Pizza, the Dragon Fire at Andre’s, or the Mediterranean with olive oil and feta cater to bold palettes.
- Stuffed & Gourmet Pizzas: Bravo leads with stuffed pizza options—ideal for sharing and hearty appetites.
Dietary Accommodators
- Gluten-Free & Lighter Fare: Both Andre’s and Bravo offer gluten-free pizza, while most pizzerias feature salads, lighter flatbreads, or veggie-forward options.
Complementary Menu Choices
- Appetizers & Sides: Breadsticks, garlic knots, creative French fry variations (e.g., Bravo’s Loaded French Fry Pizza), and salads abound.
- Italian Classics: Handmade pastas, strombolis, subs, and signature entrees at Margherita’s, La Sicilia, and Andre’s provide variety when a group can’t agree on pizza alone.
Installation Tips: Ordering, Picking Up, and Enjoying Your Oxford Pizza
While you won’t be installing a pizza in a car, there are “installation”-like best practices to ensure the best experience:
Ordering
- Check for Online Ordering: Most major places (Bravo, Andre’s, Margherita’s, Pats Select) offer online or phone ordering. This speeds up the process and limits wait time.
- Specify Allergies and Preferences: Always call ahead if you have dietary restrictions or want specific customizations.
Picking Up or Delivery
- Carry-Out Tips: Bring an insulated pizza bag or towel for long drives to maintain heat.
- Delivery Window: Try to order outside peak dinner hours for the fastest, freshest experience.
- Contactless Delivery: If preferred, request contactless service; some shops (like La Sicilia) accommodate this for safety and convenience.
Keeping Pizza Fresh in Your Car
- Use Your Car Heater (in cold weather): If transporting pizza, direct floor vents toward the box to keep it warm without steaming the crust.
- Flat Transport: Keep pizza boxes flat on the car seat or trunk to avoid cheese or toppings sliding.
- Timing: For best taste, eat pizza within 30 minutes of pickup or delivery.
Maintenance Advice: Ensuring Your Pizza Experience Remains Stellar
Having great pizza once is wonderful—but what about keeping the quality high for leftovers or repeated visits?
Storing Leftovers
- Immediate Transfer: Move leftover slices from the box to an airtight container or wrap in foil for short-term fridge storage (up to 3 days).
- Layering: Place parchment or wax paper between slices to prevent sticking.
Reheating Pizza
- Oven Method (Best): Preheat oven to 375°F, place slices on foil or a baking sheet, and heat for 8-10 minutes. This restores crispness.
- Skillet Method: Warm slices on medium heat in a covered skillet for 3-5 minutes.
- Avoid Microwaving: While easy, microwaves can make crusts chewy; only use if you’re short on time.
Cleaning Up (Post-Pizza)
- Disposal: Recycle pizza boxes if your municipality allows—remove liners and excessive food residue.
- Sanitize Surfaces: Wipe down dining areas, especially if you enjoyed a BYOB dinner with the family.
Practical Tips and Best Practices for Choosing and Using Pizza in Oxford, PA
1. Consider Your Pizza Style Preferences
- If you crave thick and chewy, go for Sicilian or deep-dish offerings.
- For crispy, New York-style is your best bet.
- Prefer Mediterranean flair? Try gourmet or specialty pizzas with feta, fresh greens, and olive oil.
2. Dietary Needs
- Gluten-free options are more readily available than ever, but always double-check about cross-contamination.
- Many places are vegetarian-friendly, but vegan cheese may not be standard.
3. Group and Event Logistics
- Large family or party? Pre-order or call ahead to ensure timely service and seating.
- For potlucks or work events, opt for sheet/Sicilian pizzas for easy sharing.
4. Pizza and Peripherals
- Pair with house-made salads, classic garlic knots, or loaded fries for a memorable meal.
- If BYOB, chill your beverages ahead and bring your favorite wine or craft beer to Margherita’s or La Sicilia.
5. Timing Is Everything
- For freshest pies, avoid heavy rush periods (typically 6-7:30pm on weekends).
- If you have a favorite topping or style, mention it during order (house specialties are often made fresh and quickly).
6. Customization
- Most local pizza spots allow ingredient swaps, custom combos, and special requests—don’t hesitate to ask.
7. Value and Specials
- Many shops offer family deals, combo meals, or slice specials, especially during lunch hours or mid-week.
Key Feature Comparison Table: Pizza Styles and Attributes in Oxford, PA
| Pizza Style/Type | Crust Texture | Slice Size | Topping Choices | Popular Venues | Gluten-Free Available | Price Range (Whole Pie) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Neapolitan | Thin, soft, slightly chewy | Medium-Large | Classic (cheese, basil, tomato), gourmet | Bravo, Margherita’s | At Bravo | $12.99-$16.99 |
| NY-style | Thin, crisp, foldable | Large | Traditional & creative | Andre’s, Bravo | Andre’s | $16.99 and up |
| Sicilian | Thick, airy, focaccia-like | Square, big | Cheese, tomato sauce, meats | Andre’s, Bravo | Check (rare) | $18.99-$25.99 |
| Deep Dish | Thick, buttery, pan-baked | Large, wedge | Cheese-heavy, tomato-rich | Bravo | Not standard | $18.99-$19.49 |
| White Pizza | Soft to crisp, no sauce | Medium | Garlic, cheese, veggies | All venues | Andre’s, Bravo | $13.49-$16.99 |
| Gourmet/Specialty | Varies (often thin/medium) | Varies | Seasonal, global, fusion | Bravo, Andre’s | Bravo, Andre’s | $13.99-$19.99 |
| Gluten-Free | Thin, sometimes crispy | Small-Medium | Classic and select specialty | Andre’s, Bravo | Yes | $11.99-$18.99 |
Related Video
Conclusion
Oxford, PA’s pizza scene delights with its variety—whether you crave the satisfying crunch of a New York-style pie, the comfort of Sicilian slabs, or distinctive gourmet creations with unique toppings. Family-owned standouts like Margherita’s and La Sicilia offer authentic Italian hospitality and handmade specialties, perfect for leisurely evenings or BYOB gatherings. Andre’s and Bravo Pizza shine with robust menus, creative flavors, and gluten-free selections ideal for adventurous and health-conscious eaters alike.
When choosing your next pizza outing or takeout night, consider your preferred pizza style, dietary needs, group size, and desire for extras like BYOB or catering. Each local spot offers its own charm and specialties, so don’t hesitate to try a few to find your personal favorite. Whichever you choose, Oxford’s pizza restaurants promise a satisfying meal for every palate and occasion.
FAQ
- How do I choose the best pizza restaurant in Oxford, PA?
Start by considering your preferred pizza style (thin crust, Sicilian, deep-dish, etc.), dietary needs (such as gluten-free options), and dining preferences (dine-in, takeout, delivery, BYOB). Many families enjoy Margherita’s or La Sicilia for atmosphere, while Andre’s and Bravo are favored for robust menus and customization.
- Are gluten-free pizzas available in Oxford?
Yes, both Bravo Pizza and Andre’s Pizza offer gluten-free pizza options. If you have severe allergies, always confirm about cross-contamination procedures before ordering.
- What are the most popular pizza flavors or styles in Oxford?
Classics like Margherita, NY-style cheese, Sicilian, and Meat Lovers remain favorites. Adventurous eaters may enjoy specialty pizzas such as Dragon Fire, Taco Pizza, or Mediterranean-inspired pies.
- Which pizza spots in Oxford are best for families?
Margherita’s Pizza, La Sicilia, and André’s Pizza offer family-friendly dining, generous portions, and welcoming atmospheres. Pats Select also appeals to families with its broad menu and catering options.
- Do any pizza places in Oxford offer BYOB?
Yes, Margherita’s Italian Restaurant and La Sicilia Pizza Pasta Grille are BYOB. They provide glasses, making it easy to bring your own wine, beer, or spirits for a relaxing meal.
- What’s the best way to reheat leftover pizza for the best taste?
Reheat pizza in a preheated oven at 375°F for 8–10 minutes or in a covered skillet on the stovetop. This preserves the crust’s texture and flavor better than microwaving.
- Can I order pizza online for delivery or pickup in Oxford?
Absolutely. Most major pizza places (Bravo, Andre’s, Pats Select) allow for online ordering and provide both takeout and delivery services. Contactless delivery is also available at select venues.
- Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Oxford, PA?
Many pizza restaurants, including Bravo and Andre’s, have plenty of vegetarian pizzas and salads. Strict vegan options (like vegan cheese) aren’t always standard, so ask about availability when ordering.
- What other menu items can I find at Oxford’s pizza restaurants?
In addition to pizza, you’ll find strombolis, calzones, pastas, subs, wings, appetizers like garlic knots or mozzarella sticks, and fresh salads. Some venues are known for their sandwiches and Italian entrees.
- Do any places in Oxford, PA cater for larger parties or events?
Yes, Pats Select specifically offers catering and family-meal deals. Most pizza spots gladly accept large orders for events—call ahead to arrange timely preparation and pick-up or delivery.
